Why Does God Allow Pain & Suffering? Exploring Free Will and Divine Purpose

Photo by Marc-Olivier Jodoin on Unsplash

Many of us grapple with the question: Why does God allow pain and suffering? It's a question that touches the core of our faith, our understanding of God’s nature, and the reality we live in. In moments of betrayal, loss, or hardship, this question can feel especially urgent and personal. Drawing from insights shared by Kerry Decker and Karen Johnson of New Destiny Coaching, this article delves into the complex relationship between God, free will, and the existence of pain and suffering in our world.

The Foundation: Free Will and Human Choice

At the heart of understanding why God allows pain and suffering lies the concept of free will. Free will is the God-given ability to choose—to love, to obey, or to rebel. Without it, life would not be life as we know it; it would be mere programming or puppetry. As one pastor put it, if God created humanity without free will, we would be like robots forced to love and obey, lacking the genuine relationships and meaningful choices that define human existence.

This freedom to choose is essential because it allows for true love and genuine relationships, not only with God but also among people. Without free will, love would be meaningless. The ability to make choices, including wrong ones, inevitably opens the door to pain and suffering.

Genesis and the Two Trees

In the early chapters of Genesis, God places two trees in the Garden of Eden: the Tree of Life and the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. Humanity was free to eat from any tree except the latter, which God warned would lead to suffering and death. Yet, Adam and Eve chose to eat from the forbidden tree, exercising their free will in a way that brought suffering into the world.

This story highlights a profound truth: God did not create a world where evil was inevitable, but He allowed for the possibility of evil by giving humans the freedom to choose. The choice to disobey was theirs, not God’s. This distinction is crucial because while God made evil possible, He did not make evil actual.

Making Sense of God’s Role in Pain and Suffering

One common question is whether God is complicit in the pain and suffering that occur, given that He created free will and the conditions under which evil could arise. This question is complex and has been explored by theologians and Christian apologists for centuries. Here’s a helpful analogy that sheds light on this issue:

Imagine the world’s best automobile manufacturer designing vehicles to the highest standards possible. Although the cars are built well, accidents may still happen because drivers can be inattentive, intoxicated, or reckless. The manufacturer has created something good, but the potential for harm exists due to human choices. The manufacturer is not responsible for those accidents, only for producing a reliable vehicle.

Similarly, God created a world with the potential for good and the possibility of evil, but the actual evil and suffering result from human misuse of free will, not from God’s direct intention or desire.

Freedom Comes with Responsibility

Freedom to choose inherently includes the possibility of making wrong choices that lead to suffering. But without this freedom, the good that comes from making right choices wouldn’t be possible either. True goodness, love, and joy require the freedom to choose them.

As one insightful reflection put it, “You can’t have choice without pain and suffering, but you also can’t have the good stuff that comes with making good choices.” This balance is essential to understanding why God allows pain and suffering in a world where free will exists.

The Nature of Free Will: Beyond Instinct

Humans are unique in creation because we are not driven solely by instinct, like animals. While animals act on instinct and natural drives, humans are described by Aristotle as “rational animals.” This means we have the capacity to reason, reflect, and make deliberate choices, which depend on free will.

Our ability to choose ideas, beliefs, and actions sets us apart. Without free will, we wouldn’t be capable of true love, moral responsibility, or spiritual growth. This rationality and freedom come with the risk of pain and suffering but are fundamental to the human experience.

Does Free Will Necessarily Require Suffering?

Some might say that free will always entails suffering. However, there is hope beyond this idea. Reflecting on eternity, many believe that in heaven, free will will exist without the accompanying pain and suffering that we experience now.

One way to understand this is through the analogy of illness and healing. Imagine a person suffering from a terrible disease like cancer. The disease brings immense pain and limitation. When the person is cured, their life is restored and transformed. They would never wish to return to the suffering, even though they had experienced it deeply.

Similarly, life on earth includes suffering, but the promise of heaven is a restoration where free will continues, but pain and suffering do not. This hope inspires believers to endure the trials of this fallen world.

Explore Our Coaching Services

Discover How New Destiny Coaching Can Help You

Learn More

Why Doesn't God Stop Tragic Events?

One of the most difficult questions is why God doesn’t intervene to stop tragedies and evil acts, like the Oklahoma City bombing, for example. This tragic event took many lives and caused immense suffering. Why didn’t God stop, Timothy McVeigh, before he killed so many?

Here’s a perspective to consider: If God intervened every time someone was about to do evil, it would remove human freedom. The ability to choose—even to choose wrongly—is essential to the kind of authentic relationships God desires with us.

Moreover, this question challenges us to think more broadly. We often ask why God doesn’t stop evil that we deplore, but we seldom ask why He doesn’t stop the evil that we ourselves commit. If God stopped every wrong act, where would that leave humanity’s responsibility and freedom?

The Gates of the Oklahoma City Memorial

The Oklahoma City Bombing Memorial beautifully symbolizes this journey through suffering and healing. It features two gates:

The Gate of Innocence: Representing the time before suffering, a state of innocence everyone experiences before facing hardship.
The Gate of Healing: Symbolizing hope and restoration after suffering.

We all walk through the gate of innocence into a world where suffering and heartbreak are inevitable. Yet, there is also a path toward healing—a journey that faith, community, and God’s grace can help us navigate.

Jesus: The Ultimate Example of Free Will and Love

One of the most profound aspects of this discussion is the role of Jesus Christ. Jesus exercised His free will in choosing to give Himself up for humanity. His sacrifice is the ultimate example of love freely given, not forced or robotic obedience.

Jesus is often described as a “Man of Sorrows, acquainted with grief,” who did not stand apart from human suffering but entered into it fully. His life and death show us that God is not distant or detached from our pain but intimately involved and compassionate.

Finding Healing Beyond Betrayal and Pain

Many people who suffer betrayal or deep hurt wrestle with feelings of anger and confusion toward God. It’s natural to ask, Why does God allow this pain? The journey toward healing involves honest questions, reflection, and support.

Programs like Beyond Betrayal offer resources and guidance for those struggling with these difficult emotions. The goal is to help individuals move from pain to healing, finding peace and understanding in the midst of life’s challenges.

Conclusion: Embracing Freedom, Responsibility, and Hope

The question “Why does God allow pain and suffering?” is complex and deeply personal. The key to understanding it lies in recognizing the role of free will—God’s gift that allows us to love, choose, and grow but also opens the door to suffering.

God did not cause evil or suffering but permitted the possibility because true freedom requires it. Pain and suffering are real and often difficult, but they are not the final word. The promise of healing, restoration, and eternal life offers hope beyond the trials of this world.

As we navigate this difficult terrain, we can take comfort in knowing that God is with us, that Jesus entered into our suffering, and that through faith and community, healing is possible.

If you are struggling with pain, betrayal, or anger toward God, know that you are not alone. We want to support your healing and peace.